An Adventure Based Text Set and Rationale
In
each human being is the desire for adventure. Whether the adventure is a
physical striking out and scouting of uncharted territory, or living through
another’s adventures written as literature, the concept is
something that every person can relate to. Another commonality in human beings
is their desire to unscramble the elusive meaning of life. We all have these
gargantuan, massive questions and their answers almost always seem to allude
us. These two aspects of life have always haunted my mind, and I find their
mystery and ability to conform to each individual in this life captivating and
a characteristic that will always draw me to want to learn more to answer the questions that are produced by these ideas. It is this need for adventure and the desire to seek out the meaning
of life that has lead me to choose these three novels as the material for my
text set: Into the Wild written by Jon Krakauer, The River Why by
David James Duncan, and A River Runs Through It by Norman Maclean. In
all three of these novels, the protagonist is troubled by some aspect of life
that eludes them. In large, this aspect is more poignantly known as “the
meaning of life.” In the first two novels, the main characters strike out from
what they know, seeking to leave their pasts behind them and obtain some deeper
meaning to their lives through solitude and the emersion of the activities that
mean the most to them. The third novel, A River Runs Through It follows
a similar pattern, however, the main character is fully aware of where to go to
achieve this deeper meaning-at least an aspect of it. By providing this text
set to a class of high school students, I will be offering the opportunity to
be lost in a sense of adventure while at the same time triggering the search
for each of their own personal “meanings of life.”
I have chosen to start my text set
with Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer because of its popularity in our culture,
which will make my text set appealing to students. The other reason I
have chosen to use this book to head off my set is that unlike the
other two, this novel has nothing to do with fishing and focuses solely
on the importance of adventure and seeking the meaning of life. The
other two novels use fishing as a vehicle for this which may deter the purpose of the
set and readers who frankly have no interest in fishing. I want to stress the
point that my intentions of this text set are to explore the important aspects
of life, NOT to just read books about people who fish and have fun fishing
stories. Fishing is merely a vehicle that both of the authors used, therefore I
chose to head off my set with Krakauer’s novel so that my readers would have a
strong sense of the main ideas of the set preventing them from being distracted
by the concept and art of fishing. With that said, I will now dive into the
connecting themes that are introduced in my novel:
In Krakauer’s Into the Wild,
the main character legally known as Chris McCandless is frustrated with
society's materialistic views of the world, and is disgusted with how engulfed
in materialism his parents are. He cooperates with their request that he
attends college, but as soon as he completes his parents desires he decides to
rid himself of excess and take off on his Tolstoyan journey across the country,
changing his name and fleeing from all governmental and societal laws. Living
as a “leathertramp”, Chris journeys from state to state leaving lifelong
impacts on the people he meets along the way. The novel is a collection of
letters written by McCandless to the people he meets on his journey, and
information that Krakauer unearthed during interviews with the people that encountered
Chris. In all of his journal entries, Chris (or Alex) stresses how happy he is
to be finally living free, and discovering what his favored authors like
Tolstoy, Thoreau, and London wrote about in their literature. The main
overlapping theme of adventure and the importance of it can be found in Alex’s
relationship with Ronald Franz, a man that he met along the way that he
arguably left the strongest impact with. Ron, a retired veteran, took Alex in
and grew so attached to him that he asked that Alex take on his name as an
adopted grandson to continue his family line. Ron had once lived an exciting
life, but after the death of his wife and child was left a recluse that relied
on the safety of inactivity to comfort him. In a final letter written to Ron
before his journey into Alaska, Chris writes:
So
many people live within unhappy circumstances and yet will not take the
initiative to change their situation because they are conditioned to a life of
security, conformity, and conservatism, all of which may appear to give one
peace of mind, but in reality nothing is more damaging to the adventurous
spirit within a man than a secure future. The very basic core of a man's living
spirit is his passion for adventure. The joy of life comes from our encounters with
new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly
changing horizon, for each day to have a new and different sun. (56-57)
In this quote, Chris is directly addressing the stability
that modern Americans strive for, and in a gentle way urgently expressing how
people need to flee from that mindset in order to truly live. With my hopes of teaching in Montana, I’m hoping that this quote will inspire my students that have
fallen into the unfortunate succubus of video games to toss aside their
electronics and go out and seek the world. I also hope that it will inspire my
students that are held back by financial restraints to leave their comfort zone
and experience what their lives could be if they ignored the shackles of their pre-existing circumstances. This theme of going out to seek adventure and achieve
true meaning rings true in each of the novels that I have selected for my text
set. It is the foundation for the final theme that I find is the most
important, which will be discussed later in my piece. Like his un-hypocritical
way of living, Chris ventures off into a life of solitude, but in his later journal entries the reader finds something even more
profound than the value of taking off on a solo journey to experience the true
meaning of the wild. Once Chris has achieved this loneliness, he learns that
“happiness is only real when shared” (189). The idea that fleeing from society
only to find that companionship and love are what we truly need to survive in
this world is a theme that occurs in each novel provided in this text set, and
unfortunately for Christopher McCandless, he discovers this at the end of his
life just before he dies of starvation.
The second
novel in my text set, The River Why by David James Duncan follows a
strikingly similar plot to that of Into the Wild, however, the main
character does not go to the extremes that Chris does. In this particular
novel, the main character is a young man named Gus Orviston who is the son of
two very different fisherman, becomes fed up with his parents (like Chris), and retreats to a remote cabin on the Oregon Coast’s Tamanawis River to live out his ideal schedule of maximum
fishing time. Gus does not take off on his journey with the intentions of
finding the meaning of life, but is addressed with the question after a hike
where he has an expansive view of the river he has chosen to reside upon. After
becoming engulfed in the river and crazed by its ever present sounds of rushing
water, Gus records in his journal:
Then I
stopped, gaped, and burst out laughing as the morning up here with Bill Bob
came back to me: he’d said he liked the Tamanawis River-he, the driest of the
dry-and when I asked Why, he laughed
and said that was exactly what the river was asking me. Not till now did I
catch his drift. There were the letters, there was the word: plain as water, in
a flowing, utterly uncrabbed hand, current, erosion, gravity and chance had
written Why upon the valley floor!
Billions of ever-changing, ever the same gallons of gurgling sun-and-moon
washed ink, spelling forever, in plain English, Why. (131)
Throughout Gus’s childhood, he mentions that his parents
introduced him to the idea of God, although his teaching from the Orviston
household seemed to run parallel in terms of importance with those of Izaak
Walton’s. He had never felt empty in a
spiritual sense before leaving, but once the river bombarded his mind with this
question he was left a man on a mission to find the answer to the question that
his beloved river had been asking him as soon as he made residence. This
question taunts Gus, even more so after he meets the beautiful fisherwoman
named Eddy. Eddy becomes the character who deters Gus from everything he was
working for, and instead of being able to continue his life of solitude, he
finds his mind flooded with thoughts about her. It is Eddy who brings Gus and
his family back together on the Tamanawis, leading to his satisfaction and
completion of the circle of loneliness that he was confronted with. At the
beginning of the novel upon Gus’s family’s leaving, he realizes “Then they were
gone and I was surprised by my sadness. So much of my reason for coming here
had been to escape them-but our last bizarre night had seemed to have altered
all that” (68), but at the end of the novel Gus comes around with the addition
of Eddy and the reintroduction of his family back into his life and says “It
was of the line of light and of the touch of the hand of love that I wanted to
speak. Now I’ve spoken, or tried…I’m just living happily ever after. That is,
I’m being hung by the heart until dead” (280). Once again, the theme of
companionship and love arises in this novel, and the truth that happiness is
only achieved in the company of those you love is brought to the forefront.
I have
chosen to bring my text set full circle with Norman Maclean’s A River Runs
Through It. Unlike the preceding two novels, the main character, Norman, is
aware of the importance of family and finds that they are closest when fishing
on the Big Blackfoot River. The book is an exploration of the adventures of
Norman and Paul, two brothers who are from Missoula, Montana. The only striking
out in the novel is Norman’s leaving for college in Chicago, but he returns
after to rejoin his family. Seeing as the novel is autobiographical, it ends
with a reflection from Norman after he has outlived his loved ones: “Now early
all those I loved and did not understand when I was young are dead, but I still
reach out to them” (104). This emphasizes the togetherness that Norman values,
and how important it was in his life.
How the
themes interact within these three novels is very dependent upon
the order, and the order of the novels largely drives the points that I am
attempting to drive home with this text set. By beginning with Krakauer’s Into
the Wild, the values found upon striking out into the wilderness to flee
from materialism and dependencies are majorly highlighted. Chris’s main goal is
to live off of the land to achieve deeper meaning, and to experience the same
revelations as his idols, Thorough and Jack London. Chris aims to expel
everything from his previous life except for his sister Carine. Gus in The
River Why is frustrated with his parents, but not with all of society. His
leaving home is similar to Chris’s because of the desire to escape his parents,
but more largely to live out his ideal schedule. Unlike Chris, he is reunited
with his family in the end and makes the connection that living in love and
company is the way to achieve absolute happiness, and he is fortunate enough to
live out this realization. The circle is completed in the final novel, A
River Runs Through It because from the beginning of the novel, Norman is
aware that the key to happiness is family and togetherness, and the river is
only a vehicle to strengthen that togetherness-not an escape. This circle of
discovery is apparent in the order of my novels, and the journey of discovery
is an aspect that I would like to drive home with the order I have chosen: 1.
Man leaves, discovers happiness occurs with togetherness, dies, 2. Man leaves,
finds true happiness in the company of loved ones, returns to society and lives
his life in love, 3. Man knows that love and togetherness are the key to
happiness and loses those he loves as time moves forward.
Love and
companionship are feelings and experiences that everyone in this world can
relate to in some way. In my three novels, my readers will be able to make a
journey with each individual character, but more largely, join the three novels
together to make a discovery and larger journey that will help them develop as
people. I believe that the themes of love and companionship and not only for
girly romance novels that only girls will enjoy, but that they are themes that
are strengthened and made deeper when used in context of adventure and focus on
the ideals of family. I hope that reading these three novels in this
order will help strengthen the truth of these main concepts in my readers as it did within my own mind and heart:
that striking out on adventure is a wonderful way to find deeper meaning and
achieve self-discovery, but in the end, that happiness can only be fully
experienced when shared.